Accomplishments

Just some of our notable jury trial results

Steven and Brian Chackman tried this case before Judge William Thomas in Dade County, Florida. The jury determined that there was no accidental direct physical loss to the property as a result of the hurricane.

Steven and Brian Chackman tried this case before Michael Robinson in Broward County, Florida. The jury determined that there was no direct physical loss to the property as a result of a p-trap leak.

Steven and Brian Chackman tried this case before Judge David Haimes in Broward County, Florida. The jury determined that there was no accidental direct physical loss to the property as a result of the hurricane.

Steven Chackman obtained a final summary judgment in an errors and omissions claim against an insurance agent alleging that the agent was negligent in the procurement of a homeowners insurance policy which contained a sublimit for water damage claims.

Lisbetty Rozon obtained a final summary judgment before Judge Beatrice Butchko in Miami-Dade County. The Court ruled that there was no coverage for the claim, due to the fact that the insured repaired the property prior to notifying the insurer of the claim, thus prejudicing the insurer in its investigation.

Lisbetty Rozon obtained a final summary judgment before Judge John Bowman in Broward County. Plaintiff claimed that his property was damaged as a result of leakage from an air conditioning unit.  The Court found that Plaintiffs failed to provide sufficient evidence to rebut Defendant’s finding and observation that the claimed loss was caused by repeated seepage or leakage of water coming from the unit.

Jonathan Liss tried this case before Judge Beatrice Butchko. Plaintiff claimed to have been run off the road by a “phantom” driver. Plaintiff sustained fractures of the hand. The jury agreed with the defense argument that the plaintiff ran herself off the road, into a tree, despite the claim of a phantom driver, and returned a defense verdict.

Jonathan Liss and Douglas De Almeida tried this case before Judge Lisa Walsh in Miami. The defendant admitted fault and the plaintiff, who had no past history of shoulder injuries, ultimately had shoulder surgery after the accident for claimed injuries. The jury found that there was no negligence of the defendant that was a legal cause of injury to the plaintiff.

Douglas De Almeida and Jonathan Liss tried this case before Judge Norma Lindsey.  Plaintiff motorcyclist claimed that the defendant driver violated his right of way on A1A on Miami Beach and struck his motorcycle causing serious leg injuries. The jury found the accident to be the exclusive fault of the motorcyclist.

Jonathan Liss tried this case on behalf of a sixteen year old motorist who turned left into oncoming traffic. The plaintiff driver sustained alleged back injury , and ultimately had lumbar fusion surgery. The jury found the plaintiff 40 percent at fault for the crash and awarded no damages for the lumbar injury or surgery. The case was tried before Judge Abby Cynamon in Miami.

Jonathan Liss tried this case in Miami before Judge Antonio Arzola. Plaintiff had back surgery allegedly related to a crash claimed to have been caused by a dump truck driver who was claimed to have allowed materials to spill from his truck, obscuring the view of a motorist. The jury found no negligence on behalf of the dump truck driver, resulting in a defense verdict for the defendant insurer.

This case was tried by Jonathan Liss before Judge Victoria Sigler in Miami. Plaintiff alleged that the defendant ran a red light, or violated the right of way of the plaintiff. The plaintiff car had major damage. The plaintiff had multiple injections and neck surgery. The jury awarded no damages for the injections and the surgery and found the plaintiff 40 percent at fault for the crash.

Jonathan Liss tried this case before Judge Edward Fine in West Palm Beach. Bernstein Chackman Liss’ client admitted fault for the crash. The plaintiff claimed a neck injury that allegedly required surgery. The jury awarded zero damages.

Plaintiff sued client of Bernstein Chackman Liss for allegedly violating the right of way at a 4 way stop. Plaintiff had neck surgery. Defendant claimed the plaintiff was at fault and distracted by her cell phone. The jury returned a defense verdict. Case was tried in Miami before Judge Jerald Bagley.

Jonathan Liss tried this case for the defendant insurer. Fault of the  driver was admitted for driving into a building. The plaintiff was an occupant of the building. The defense proved the claimed injuries were pre existing conditions and awarded no damages. This case was tried in Miami before Judge Ronald Dresnick.

Jonathan  Liss tried this case in front of Judge Ronald Dresnick in Miami. The defendant insurer was sued for negligence of a driver who died in this collision, The plaintiff sustained serious injuries. The jury concluded that the accident was caused by the exclusive fault of the plaintiff, who crossed the center line into oncoming traffic.